T. Spangehl et al.: Intercomparing the quality of recent reanalyses for offshore wind farm planning 113
(2023), COSMO-CLM is evaluated and used to study cluster-
scale wake effects of wind farms in the North Sea.
A horizontal grid spacing of 0.0275? (? 3 km) is used
together with 50 vertical levels and 25 s time stepping.
The simulation starts in December 1969 with 13 months
spin-up time and is extended regularly close to real-
time. Currently, the most commonly used variables of this
dataset are available for the time period 1971–2019 on the
DWD node of the ESGF (Earth System Grid Federation)
as version V2022.01 (https://esgf.dwd.de/projects/dwd-cps/
hoklisim-v2022-01, last access: 6 November 2023, Brienen
et al., 2022). The model domain covers 461x481 grid points
and is centered around Germany. The forcing at the lat-
eral boundaries has been updated every hour for the ERA5
period in a direct nesting approach. For ERA40, 6-hourly
boundary data from an intermediate nesting simulation at
0.11? (? 12 km) have been used, which had been run using
the same configuration as in the EURO-CORDEX-CMIP5
simulations with COSMO-CLM (see e.g. Kotlarski et al.,
2014; Vautard et al., 2021). For this study, the wind com-
ponents which have been interpolated inside the model to the
100 m a.g.l. are investigated.
2.2.2 NEWA (New European Wind Atlas)
The New European Wind Atlas (NEWA) covers the 30-year
period from 1989 to 2018. The Weather Research and Fore-
casting (WRF) model was used together with ERA5 as driv-
ing reanalysis for a series of one-way nested simulations. The
simulation’s design is optimised to represent wind speed dis-
tributions in complex terrain. Three nested domains with a
resolution of 27, 9 and 3 km were used. Spectral nudging
was applied in the outer domain to incorporate the observed
large-scale atmospheric patterns. The simulations consist of
7 d periods using a spin-up of 24 h to achieve equilibrium of
the mesoscale flow with the terrain. In the vertical the model
incorporates 61 levels with the model top at 50 hPa. Data is
available for 30 min intervals for wind energy relevant pa-
rameters. Details are given by Hahmann et al. (2020) and
Dörenkämper et al. (2020). Data for 2005–2018 is publicly
available via the website https://map.neweuropeanwindatlas.
eu/ (last access: 6 November 2023). The WRF model output
was further downscaled to create the microscale atlas. In the
present study the mescoscale data at 3 km resolution is used.
2.3 FINO observations
2.3.1 FINO (Ger. Forschungsplattformen in Nord- und
Ostsee)
The FINO research platforms facilitate the exploration of off-
shore conditions and help to determine the effects of off-
shore wind energy development on marine flora and fauna.
Masts have been erected on the working platforms of FINO1,
FINO2 and FINO3, on which the most important meteoro-
logical parameters, in particular wind speed and direction at
different heights, are measured. In addition, a complete set of
hydrographic data is collected. Moreover, the forces induced
by wind and waves are measured in the foundation area (Lei-
ding et al., 2016).
In the present study measurements of wind speed and di-
rection at FINO1 are used. Wind direction data is taken from
the highest measurement level available for this parameter at
91 m a.m.s.l. (above mean sea level). The wind speed time se-
ries stems from the top anemometer at 102 m a.m.s.l. At this
height the effect of the mast on the wind speed measurement
is assumed to be small. The mast effect is corrected by apply-
ing a mast correction to the wind speed data (Leiding et al.,
2016). The mast correction depends on the wind direction.
The simultaneous wind direction measurement of the wind
vane at 91 m is included in each corrected wind speed value
in order to be able to carry out the mast correction (UL Inter-
national GmbH, personal communication, 2022). Moreover,
measurements are influenced by a lightning protection cage
which leads to slightly lower wind speeds in 4 narrowly pro-
nounced wind direction sectors (Leiding et al., 2016). Here
we estimate the overall error for all wind directions to be less
than 1 %. The time series of wind speed and direction con-
sist of 10 min averages. Hourly data at full hours is used to
enable comparability with available model output data. Ad-
ditional information on measurement uncertainties and data
availability is indicated by Leiding et al. (2016).
2.4 Satellite observations
2.5 Copernicus Marine Environment Monitoring Service
or Copernicus Marine Service (CMEMS)
Monthly averaged near-surface wind speed is
obtained from CMEMS. The CMEMS wind
product WIND_GLO_PHY_L4_MY_012_006,
https://doi.org/10.48670/moi-00185, is used. The prod-
uct incorporates scatterometer observations to correct for
persistent biases in hourly ERA5 model fields. Bias correc-
tions are based on scatterometer observations from Metop-A,
Metop-B, Metop-C ASCAT (0.125?) and QuikSCAT Sea-
Winds (0.25?). The bias corrections are calculated over 20 d
centered around the time of interest. Therefore, averaging
hourly wind speeds from this product over a month includes
some observations (10 d) from both the previous and next
month (PUM, CopernicusMarineService, personal com-
munication, 2023). The product provides stress-equivalent
Level-4 wind components at 10 m at 0.125 and 0.25?
horizontal spatial resolution and covers the period from
August 1999 to February 2023. The stress-equivalent
wind does not rely on the assumption of neutral stability
(de Kloe et al., 2017). In the present study data at 0.125?
horizontal spatial resolution is used. Hourly near-surface
wind speed is calculated from components. Monthly values
are obtained from the hourly wind speed by arithmetic
averaging. In a previous version of the manuscript the
https://doi.org/10.5194/asr-20-109-2023 Adv. Sci. Res., 20, 109–128, 2023