Marine Pollution Bulletin 194 (2023) 115396
2
relocation (Ducrotoy et al., 2000; BSH, 2016). Ocean currents in the
German Bight are directed anti clockwise with water masses entering the
bight from western directions and flowing north into the Skagerrak re-
gion via the Southern Jutland Current (Brückner and Mackensen, 2006).
The German Bight within the North Sea is considered anthropogenically
affected, which becomes particularly evident within long-term moni-
toring data (BSH, 2016). Mass fractions of legacy pollutants like Zn, Pb
and Hg often exceed background and even effect threshold values (i.e.
NOAA effect range low). In many cases elevated mass fractions are
observed near the coast, which indicates possible discharges by rivers or
other near-shore anthropogenic sources (BSH, 2009, 2016).
Currently, only a few studies were dedicated to the investigation of
the fate of metal emissions from galvanic anodes into the marine envi-
ronment. Lab-scale dissolution experiments of Zn anodes found an in-
crease of dissolved Zn concentrations, as well as increased Zn mass
fractions of marine surface sediments (Rousseau et al., 2009). A case
study within the port of Le Havre (France) evaluating the dissolution of
Al anodes showed that whilst anodic dissolution does not significantly
increase the concentration of Al in the water, both enrichment and
increased mobility of Al were evident in sediments sampled from the
vicinity of the galvanic anodes (analyzed elements: Ca, Fe, K, Mg, Al and
Si) (Gabelle et al., 2012). Furthermore, a five-year monitoring in the
port of Calais (France) showed that the dissolution of Al anodes resulted
in a higher Zn than Al enrichment of sediments. Results suggest a po-
tential toxic effect for marine organisms with regards to the discovered
Zn level, especially for confined areas with low water exchange (Caplat
et al., 2020). In addition, species-specific studies showed, that the
release of elements from galvanic anodes can pose effects on the species
of oysters (Caplat et al., 2012; Mottin et al., 2012; Golding et al., 2015;
Levallois et al., 2022), blue mussels (Mao et al., 2011; Golding et al.,
2015), sea urchins (Caplat et al., 2010; Golding et al., 2015), amphipods
(Bell et al., 2020), diatoms (Golding et al., 2015; Bell et al., 2020) and
bacteria (Bell et al., 2020) and that in combination with other stressors
such as noise the effect of a metal exposure is enhanced for biota such as
lobsters (Stenton et al., 2022). In contrast, another recent study in La
Rochelle (France) concludes that effects on the health of scallops cannot
clearly be appointed to be caused by galvanic anodes (Barbarin et al.,
2023). Moreover, the impact of climate change itself could increase
metal release and the mortality of biota inhabiting wind farms due to
higher water temperature and lower pH (Voet et al., 2022).
Recently, Wang et al. (2023) applied geo-accumulation index,
contamination factor and pollution load index to sediments taken in the
Putidao OWF (China). First hints on heavy metal pollution (Cu, Pb, Zn,
Cr and Cd) caused by OWFs were found (Wang et al., 2018). Moreover,
the authors suggest future long-term monitoring for a sound assessment
of the impact of offshore wind farms on the marine environment.
Therefore, the analysis of elemental mass fractions in sediments is
one important aspect for the assessment of long-term or emerging
contamination of aquatic systems potentially caused by the dissolution
of galvanic anodes in connection with the ongoing large-scale devel-
opment of renewable energy production worldwide. We previously
suggested a multi-tracer approach for the investigation of OWF-induced
emissions from galvanic anodes consisting of the elements Cd and Pb, as
ecotoxicologically relevant legacy pollutants, the previously discussed
main components Al and Zn and the technology-critical elements (TCEs)
In and Ga. Moreover, the application of Pb isotope ratios and element
ratios was suggested (Reese et al., 2020). Despite an increasing scientific
interest in and usage of the elements Ga and In, these elements still show
a lack of knowledge regarding their (eco)toxicity, their respective
environmental speciation and potential impact on the (marine) envi-
ronment (Filella and Rodriguez-Murillo, 2017; Romero-Freire et al.,
2019).
In addition to elemental analysis metal stable isotope ratios have
been shown to be a powerful tool for environmental source and process
tracing (Wiederhold, 2015). The isotope amount ratio n(87Sr)/n(86Sr)
can be used as a measure for the age and/or type of rocks and sediments
(Capo et al., 1998), as the relative abundance of the radiogenic isotope
87Sr increases by the radioactive ? -decay of 87Rb (t1/2 ? 4.88 ? 1010 a)
(Brand et al., 2014; de Laeter et al., 2003). Typically, finer sediment
fractions are more radiogenic than sandy sediments, due to an enrich-
ment of Rb-rich minerals in the fine sediments (Bayon et al., 2021).
Several studies have investigated Sr isotope ratios for provenancing and
characterization of sediments, e.g. (Andrews et al., 2016, Reese et al.,
2019, Bayon et al., 2021, Deng et al., 2021).
This study provides a first baseline dataset regarding the spatial and
temporal variation of galvanic anode tracer elements of German North
Sea sediments inside and within the surroundings of different OWFs over
the course of seven years. A multi-element and Sr-isotope tracer
approach was applied to assess possible inputs of metal contaminants
originating from OWFs and to differentiate from other sources. This
work can be used as the basis of future studies on potential mid- and
long-term chemical emissions and environmental effects related to the
ongoing development of renewable offshore energy production.
2. Material and methods
2.1. Reagents and materials
All preparatory laboratory work was performed in a class 10,000 or
class 1000 clean room. Type I reagent-grade water (18.2 M? cm) was
obtained from a Milli-Q Integral water purification system equipped
with a QPod-Element polishing system (Merck-Millipore, Darmstadt,
Germany). Analytical grade HNO3 (w ? 65 %, Fisher Scientific,
Schwerte, Germany) and analytical grade HCl (w ? 30 %, Carl Roth,
Karlsruhe, Germany) were further purified either by double sub-boiling
in perfluoralkoxy-polymer (PFA)-subboling stills (DST-4000 & DST-
1000, Savillex, Minnesota, USA) or by double sub-boiling using a
cascade of two quartz stills (AHF Analysentechnik, Tübingen, Germany)
operated under clean room conditions. HBF4 (w ? 38 %, Chem-Lab,
Zedelgem, Belgium) was used in ultra-pure quality for sample diges-
tion without any further purification.
External calibration standard solutions for quantification (all trace-
able to NIST standards) were prepared from custom-made multi-element
standards of different composition (Inorganic Ventures, Christiansburg,
USA).
The reference marine sediments GBW 07313 (National Research
Centre for Certified Reference Materials, Beijing, China) and the refer-
ence stream sediment GBW 07311 (National Research Centre for
Certified Reference Materials) were used for method validation.
2.2. Sampling
A total of 215 sediment samples were obtained from OWFs in the
German North Sea during six sampling campaigns with the research
vessels Atair (Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency, BSH) in
2018, 2019, 2021 and 2022 and the Ludwig Prandtl (Hereon) in 2016
and 2020. Due to logistical challenges and weather conditions not all
sampling stations were sampled in every year. Samples were taken via a
box-corer in and around selected OWFs. Due to safety reasons and legal
restrictions it was not possible to obtain samples directly next to the
foundations or in certain corridors due to the presence of the OWF un-
derwater power cables. The top layer (upper 5 cm) of three or more
individual box-cores from the same sampling station were combined,
homogenized and stored at 20 C until further analysis. A list of all
samples including GPS coordinates can be found in the electronic sup-
plementary material (ESM) Table A4. A map of all sampling locations for
the six cruises is shown in Fig. 1. Table 1 gives an overview over the
number of samples taken in the respective OWF areas per year.
A. Ebeling et al.