Ocean Dynamics (2019) 69:1217–1237
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10236-019-01299-7
Temperature assimilation into a coastal ocean-biogeochemical
model: assessment of weakly and strongly coupled data
assimilation
Michael Goodli?1,3 · Thorger Bruening2 · Fabian Schwichtenberg2 · Xin Li2 · Anja Lindenthal2 ·
Ina Lorkowski2 · Lars Nerger1
Received: 29 January 2019 / Accepted: 7 August 2019 / Published online: 5 September 2019
© Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2019
Abstract
Satellite data of both physical properties as well as ocean colour can be assimilated into coupled ocean-biogeochemical
models with the aim to improve the model state. The physical observations like sea surface temperature usually have smaller
errors than ocean colour, but it is unclear how far they can also constrain the biogeochemical model variables. Here, the
effect of assimilating satellite sea surface temperature into the coastal ocean-biogeochemical model HBM-ERGOM with
nested model grids in the North and Baltic Seas is investigated. A weakly and strongly coupled assimilation is performed
with an ensemble Kalman filter. For the weakly coupled assimilation, the assimilation only directly influences the physical
variables, while the biogeochemical variables react only dynamically during the 12-hour forecast phases in between the
assimilation times. For the strongly coupled assimilation, both the physical and biogeochemical variables are directly
updated by the assimilation. The strongly coupled assimilation is assessed in two variants using the actual concentrations
and the common approach to use the logarithm of the concentrations of the biogeochemical fields. In this coastal domain,
both the weakly and strongly coupled assimilation are stable, but only if the actual concentrations are used for the strongly
coupled case. Compared to the weakly coupled assimilation, the strongly coupled assimilation leads to stronger changes
of the biogeochemical model fields. Validating the resulting field estimates with independent in situ data shows only a
clear improvement for the temperature and for oxygen concentrations, while no clear improvement of other biogeochemical
fields was found. The oxygen concentrations were more strongly improved with strongly coupled than weakly coupled
assimilation. The experiments further indicate that for the strongly coupled assimilation of physical observations the
biogeochemical fields should be used with their actual concentrations rather than the logarithmic concentrations.
Keywords Data assimilation · Biogeochemistry · North Sea · Baltic Sea
1 Introduction
In recent years, ocean forecasting has become more common,
e.g. with the European Copernicus Marine Environment
Monitoring Service (CMEMS). In Germany, the Federal
Responsible Editor: Vassiliki Kourafalou
This article is part of the Topical Collection on Coastal Ocean
Forecasting Science supported by the GODAE OceanView Coastal
Oceans and Shelf Seas Task Team (COSS-TT) - Part II
Lars Nerger
lars.nerger@awi.de
Extended author information available on the last page of the article.
Maritime and Hydrographic Agency (BSH) operates a
forecasting system for the North and Baltic Seas based on
the HIROMB-BOOS model (HBM, see, e.g. Bruening et al.
2014). The national monitoring duties, e.g. to fulfil the
European Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD)
require monitoring the seas with regard to water quality, and
hence also for the ecosystem. Given that in situ observations
are sparse and hence insufficient for the monitoring, the
extension of forecast models with an ecosystem component
is required. A coupled ocean-biogeochemical model, which
simulates phytoplankton and nutrients, can represent, e.g.
eutrophication, but can potentially also predict harmful algal
blooms.
To initialise model forecasts, different observations can
be assimilated. Satellite observations, e.g. of temperature or