22
BSH Report No. 56
Laboratory Performance RSD (n=4)
(Based on Peak Heights of Hopanes and Steranes)
29bbR
28bbS
28bbR
27bbS
27bbR
—BSH_BioM
Fig. 12; RSD of the biomarker groups hopanes and steranes, based on the peak heights (raw
counts).
The RSD values In the radar chart are based on raw counts, expecting that
normalisation compensates for variance If the main Impact Is of a systematic
nature. Consider discussion point DP-3 on page 31.
Nevertheless, looking at the conclusion matrix (Tab. 4), It Is surprising that
matching ratios from the group of the steranes are succeeding those of the
hopanes by far.
On the other hand, positive matches are suggested for samples of set 2 from
both, RWS and BSH analysis, which contradicts the results from FID and
MS-85m/z conclusions. This observation continues Into the duplicate analyses,
where hopanes show a non-matching tendency and steranes suggest a 100%
match.
These results lead to the conclusion that the blomarkers are of very limited use
for this purpose, without further preparation or concentration of the samples
only leads to Inconclusive and erratic results.